Home › Medicine & treatments › Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT)

Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT)

Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT)

Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT) is a medication treatment used to relieve menopausal symptoms. It works by replenishing the hormones that the body has reduced during menopause, mainly estrogen, with progesterone added when needed, to improve hot flushes, night sweats, mood swings, vaginal dryness and other discomforts, and it also helps prevent osteoporosis.

Many Hong Kong women search for the benefits and risks of HRT when they enter menopause, especially because of the common misconception that 'hormones cause cancer'. In fact, HRT has different types and methods of use, and the risks vary from person to person. It must be assessed and prescribed by a doctor, and you should not buy or take it on your own.

Important Statement: The following is a summary of various viewpoints and is not medical advice; for medication and treatment, please consult a registered doctor or Chinese medicine practitioner.
[ edit intro ]

💊 What it is / How mainstream Western medicine views it

[ edit ]

HRT is the use of medication to replenish the hormones reduced during menopause. Estrogen is the main component, and it can be in tablets, patches, sprays or gels; if you still have a uterus, progesterone must be added to protect the endometrium, and it can be in tablets, combined patches or an intrauterine device. In addition, vaginal estrogen cream or suppositories can target vaginal dryness and urinary symptoms; testosterone gel or cream may help some people with reduced libido[1][2]. Doctors will decide which type of HRT to use based on whether you have periods and whether your uterus has been removed.

The benefits of HRT include relieving menopausal symptoms and preventing osteoporosis, but there are also risks to consider. Common side effects include breast tenderness, headache, nausea, etc.; serious side effects are less common but should be noted[1]. Not everyone is suitable for HRT; for example, pregnancy, unexplained vaginal bleeding, a history of certain cancers, stroke or heart disease, blood clots, liver disease and other conditions are not recommended for use[3]. A doctor must assess you before use.

EstrogenMain component of HRT
ProgesteroneProtects the endometrium
OsteoporosisHRT helps prevent
Prescription medicationRequires doctor assessment

🔬 What the latest research says

[ edit ]

A 2019 individual participant meta-analysis in The Lancet integrated data from multiple observational studies to explore the relationship between different types and timing of hormone therapy and breast cancer risk. The results showed that risk varies with duration and type of use, but such studies are observational and may not fully establish causality, and there may be confounding factors[8]. In addition, a 2021 umbrella review in PLOS Medicine synthesized multiple systematic reviews and meta-analyses to examine various associations between menopausal hormone therapy and women's health. The conclusion was that benefits and risks must be balanced, and more high-quality research is needed to clarify[9]. Overall, research supports that HRT is effective for relieving symptoms, but long-term risks require individual assessment.

🧭 Comparison of four viewpoints

[ edit ]
Mainstream Western medicine Strong evidence

HRT is an evidence-based treatment with clear effects on relieving menopausal symptoms and preventing osteoporosis, but risks vary from person to person and require doctor assessment and regular follow-up[1][2][3].

White Soldier (Stormtrooper White Soldier 'Whiteboard Medicine') Personal commentary

White Soldier has not released a special video on HRT. However, in verified video titles he mentions 'hormone toxins' and the effects of everyday chemicals, and his stance tends to focus on environmental hormones rather than medication supplementation, but this is only his personal commentary and does not represent medical guidelines.

Chinese medicine viewpoint Empirical medicine

Chinese medicine uses pattern differentiation and treatment, which differs from Western medicine mechanisms. It understands menopause from perspectives such as kidney deficiency, liver qi stagnation, and qi and blood disharmony, and uses Chinese herbs, acupuncture, etc. for regulation, focusing on overall balance, but lacks large randomized controlled trial evidence.

Pinfong Wiki Unverified

Pinfong Wiki has not released a special video on HRT. The channel states that they are not healthcare professionals; if they share any folk remedies, they are not scientifically verified, may delay treatment, and are at your own risk.

⚖️ See the differences in one table

[ edit ]
IssueWestern medicineWhite SoldierChinese medicineFolk remedies
Management of menopausal symptomsHRT is an evidence-based treatmentHas not released a special video on HRTPattern differentiation and treatmentHas not released a special video on HRT
Hormone risksVaries from person to person, doctor assessmentConcerned about environmental hormonesEmphasizes balanceUnverified
Prevention of osteoporosisHRT helpsHas not released a special video on HRTTonify kidney and strengthen bonesUnverified
Medication principlesPrescription medication, regular follow-upPersonal commentaryChinese medicine pattern differentiationAt your own risk

⚠️ Risks and contraindications

[ edit ]

HRT is not suitable for everyone. If you are pregnant, have unexplained vaginal bleeding, a history of certain cancers, stroke or heart disease, blood clots, liver disease, etc., you should not use it[3]. During use, if you experience abnormal vaginal bleeding, breast lumps, severe headache, chest pain, difficulty breathing, leg swelling, etc., you must seek medical attention immediately. You should not stop or switch medication on your own, because sudden stopping may cause symptoms to rebound; you should discuss gradual adjustment with your doctor. The risks of long-term use should be assessed regularly, and the doctor will decide how long to use it based on your situation[1][2].

❓ Frequently asked questions

[ edit ]

Q: Does HRT cause cancer?
A: Some studies show that long-term use of certain types of HRT may be associated with breast cancer risk, but the risk varies from person to person, and the benefits of relieving symptoms must be balanced. It is recommended to discuss in detail with your doctor[8][9].

Q: What types of HRT are there?
A: Mainly estrogen-only therapy, combined hormone therapy (continuous or sequential), vaginal estrogen, testosterone, etc. Doctors will choose based on whether you have a uterus and periods[1][2].

Q: How long can it be used?
A: There is no hard deadline; regular follow-up is needed to assess benefits and risks, and the doctor will decide[1].

Q: Are there non-hormonal options?
A: Yes, such as antidepressants, cognitive behavioural therapy, clonidine, etc., suitable for people who do not want or cannot use HRT[2].

📚 References

[ edit ]
  1. NHS:荷爾蒙補充療法(HRT)用藥指引
  2. NHS:更年期治療選擇
  3. MedlinePlus:荷爾蒙補充療法
  4. 世界衞生組織:更年期概況
  5. NICE:更年期診斷與管理指引(NG23)
  6. DailyMed:雌二醇(Estradiol)藥物標籤
  7. 維基百科:荷爾蒙補充療法
  8. 《刺針》2019:荷爾蒙療法類型、時機與乳癌風險的個別參與者統合分析
  9. PLOS Medicine 2021:更年期荷爾蒙治療與女性健康的傘形綜述

🎥 Videos

5 related videos · click to play

If you spot an error or have an editorial suggestion, please submit a correction.