The Kelly criterion is a formula for sizing a bet in proportion to the edge you hold. It was introduced in 1956 by John L. Kelly Jr. at Bell Labs, originally as a solution to a problem in information theory, and was later applied to blackjack and markets by Edward Thorp.
🧮 The formula
[ edit ]f* = (b × p − q) ÷ b, where p is the probability of winning, q = 1 − p, and b is the net odds received (b = 1 means even money). Equivalently, f* = edge ÷ odds.
🎯 Why that fraction
[ edit ]Kelly maximises the expected logarithm of wealth, which is the long-run growth rate of capital. Bet too little and the edge is wasted; bet too much and a losing streak cripples the bankroll.
📈 Continuous form
[ edit ]For portfolios the formula becomes f* = μ ÷ σ², which explains why more volatile assets warrant smaller allocations even when expected returns are higher.
⚖️ The cost of overbetting
[ edit ]Betting twice the Kelly fraction drives the long-run growth rate to zero; betting more than twice makes it negative — even when every bet has positive expected value.
🎲 A famous experiment: the 60% coin
[ edit ]In 2016 Haghani and Dewey gave 61 young, quantitatively trained participants US$25 and 30 minutes to bet on a coin they were told came up heads 60% of the time. The Kelly-optimal stake is 10% of capital on each flip.
Most participants bet poorly, and about 30% went bust, losing the full stake. Even trained professionals struggle to size bets optimally in the simplest possible game with a clear edge — which is why practitioners use fractional Kelly.
🧩 Fractional Kelly
[ edit ]In practice bettors use half or quarter Kelly, because p is estimated rather than known and overestimating the edge leads directly to overbetting.
🐎 Horse racing
[ edit ]William Benter's betting system used Kelly to size bets after a model estimated each runner's probability and compared it with the pari-mutuel odds. In Hong Kong the Jockey Club's 17.5% takeout must be subtracted before any edge is computed.
🔗 Related entries
[ edit ]- Horse racing betting systems — how Kelly is applied to pari-mutuel pools
- William Benter — the professional gambler who sized bets with Kelly
❓ FAQ
[ edit ]Does Kelly guarantee a profit?
No. It maximises growth only if the edge is real; a false edge simply loses money faster.
Why not bet full Kelly?
Because the true probability is unknown; estimation error makes full Kelly dangerous.
📚 References
[ edit ]- Kelly, J. L. (1956). A New Interpretation of Information Rate (PDF)
- Thorp, E. O. (2006). The Kelly Criterion in Blackjack, Sports Betting, and the Stock Market (PDF)
- Benter, W. (1995). Computer Based Horse Race Handicapping and Wagering Systems (PDF)
- Haghani, V. & Dewey, R. (2017). Rational Decision-Making Under Uncertainty: Observed Betting Patterns on a Biased Coin (arXiv)