Probiotics are live microorganisms that are intended to provide health benefits when consumed or applied, and can be found in yoghurt, fermented foods, dietary supplements and beauty products. Many people assume all microorganisms are harmful "germs", but many are actually beneficial to the human body, for example by aiding digestion, destroying disease-causing cells or producing vitamins.
In recent years, probiotic products have proliferated, and many Hong Kong people buy them to keep at home, or take them while on antibiotics in the hope of reducing diarrhoea. However, the efficacy and safety of probiotics depend on the strain and the product, and cannot be generalised.
💊 What it is / How mainstream Western medicine views it
[ edit ]The most common probiotic species include Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium, as well as yeasts such as Saccharomyces boulardii. Different types of probiotics can have different effects: the fact that one strain of Lactobacillus helps prevent a certain disease does not mean another strain has the same effect[1]. Prebiotics are different from probiotics: they are food components that cannot be digested and can selectively stimulate the growth or activity of beneficial microorganisms; products combining the two are called synbiotics[1].
Mainstream Western medicine holds that probiotics can work by maintaining and restoring the natural balance of gut flora. Australian government health information states that probiotics help prevent certain types of diarrhoea, relieve symptoms of irritable bowel syndrome, and reduce the risk of certain respiratory infections[2]. However, many claimed benefits, such as treating eczema or curing vaginal infections, lack substantial scientific support[3]. The US Food and Drug Administration lists probiotics as generally recognised as safe (GRAS), but this label does not mean they are effective or have specific health benefits[3].
🔬 What the latest research says
[ edit ]Regarding probiotics for preventing antibiotic-associated diarrhoea, a systematic review and meta-analysis published in 2021, pooling multiple randomised controlled trials, showed that probiotics may reduce the risk of antibiotic-associated diarrhoea[7]. Another meta-analysis published in 2021 in the Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology, focusing on randomised controlled trials of antibiotic-associated diarrhoea in adults, reached a similar conclusion[8]. These studies support a role for probiotics in specific situations, but the strains, doses and subjects differ across studies, and the results cannot be directly applied to all products.
Note that these conclusions apply only to the specific strains and products used in the studies. Moreover, most study subjects were adults, so extra caution is needed when applying this to children, pregnant women or immunocompromised people. The efficacy of probiotics is strain-specific, and different strains cannot substitute for one another[3].
🧭 Comparison of four viewpoints
[ edit ]Probiotics are live microorganisms; some strains help prevent antibiotic-associated diarrhoea, relieve irritable bowel symptoms and reduce the risk of respiratory infections[2]. Efficacy and safety depend on the strain, and the effects of different strains are not interchangeable[1]. Serious or fatal infections have been reported in premature infants given probiotics, and the US Food and Drug Administration has issued a warning to healthcare professionals[1].
In video titles, White Soldier raises viewpoints such as "Why probiotics don't work?" and "Strain count ≠ effective!", questioning the common emphasis on bacterial count alone, and stressing that probiotics and prebiotics are different[9]. In another video title, he mentions that gut bacteria are linked to the brain[10]. These are personal commentaries and do not constitute medical advice.
Chinese medicine uses pattern differentiation and treatment, which differs from Western medical mechanisms. Chinese medicine emphasises overall balance and spleen-stomach function, and does not consider probiotics by strain alone, but prescribes according to constitution and pattern. Probiotics are not traditional Chinese medicine; consult a registered Chinese medicine practitioner before use.
In a video title, Pinfong Wiki mentions "the 1300-year longevity secret of Caucasians - the secret to a young gut"[11]; the channel states it is not healthcare personnel, the content is personal sharing and scientifically unverified, and following such practices may carry risks.
⚖️ Differences at a glance
[ edit ]| Issue | Western medicine | White Soldier | Chinese medicine | Pinfong |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Key to efficacy | Depends on the specific strain | Questions whether a higher count means efficacy | Pattern differentiation by constitution | Emphasises a longevity secret |
| Role of prebiotics | Different from probiotics | Stresses probiotics ≠ prebiotics | Discussed less | Discussed less |
| Safety risks | Serious infections reported in premature infants | No dedicated video on safety risks | Consult a Chinese medicine practitioner | Unverified, carries risks |
| Evidence base | Systematic reviews and meta-analyses | Personal commentary and video titles | Empirical medicine | Personal sharing |
⚠️ Risks and contraindications
[ edit ]Although probiotics are generally considered safe, serious and even fatal infections have been reported in premature infants after use, and the US Food and Drug Administration has issued a warning to healthcare professionals on this[1]. Immunocompromised people, critically ill patients or those with serious illness must consult a doctor before use. If persistent diarrhoea, fever, dehydration or blood in the stool occurs, seek medical attention promptly[4]. Probiotics cannot replace medication prescribed by a doctor.
❓ Frequently asked questions
[ edit ]Q: What is the difference between probiotics and prebiotics?
A: Probiotics are live microorganisms; prebiotics are food components that cannot be digested and can selectively stimulate the growth or activity of beneficial microorganisms; products combining the two are called synbiotics[1].
Q: Are probiotics with a higher count more effective?
A: Not necessarily. The efficacy of probiotics depends on the strain, different strains have different effects, and a higher count does not necessarily mean greater efficacy[1].
Q: Can I take probiotics while on antibiotics?
A: Research suggests probiotics may help prevent antibiotic-associated diarrhoea[7][8], but it is best to consult a doctor before use, especially for immunocompromised people.
Q: Who should not take probiotics?
A: Premature infants, immunocompromised people or critically ill patients must consult a doctor before use[1].
📚 References
[ edit ]- 美國國家輔助及整合健康中心:益生菌須知
- Healthdirect(澳洲政府):益生菌
- 維基百科:益生菌
- NHS:腹瀉(Diarrhoea)
- DailyMed:乳酸菌產品標籤
- 香港衞生署:主要服務範圍
- BMJ Open 2021:益生菌預防抗生素相關腹瀉的系統綜述與統合分析
- Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology 2021:成人抗生素相關腹瀉的隨機對照試驗統合分析
🎥 Videos
5 related videos · click to play
Play



