Knee pain is one of the most common musculoskeletal complaints in Hong Kong, spanning sports injuries in younger people and degenerative change in older adults. Most patients arrive with two questions: is my cartilage worn away, and do I need surgery? Research over the past decade has rewritten the answers to both.
🩺 What Western medicine does
[ edit ]Assessment starts with history and examination rather than imaging: when it hurts, whether the pain is medial or lateral, going up and down stairs versus walking on the flat, swelling, locking or giving way. NICE's 2022 guideline states that osteoarthritis is diagnosed clinically and usually does not need imaging to confirm the diagnosis[1].
Once degenerative knee osteoarthritis is diagnosed, NICE separates treatment into two layers. The core treatments are therapeutic exercise and weight management where appropriate, plus information and support. For people living with overweight or obesity, the guideline advises that weight loss improves pain, function and quality of life, and that losing 10% of body weight is likely to be better than 5%[1].
Pharmacologically NICE is conservative: do not offer glucosamine, do not offer strong opioids, and start with topical NSAIDs before considering oral agents. Intra-articular steroid injections can give short-term relief but wear off. Referral for joint replacement is reserved for severe pain with failed conservative treatment and impaired quality of life[1]. Arthroscopic lavage and debridement are explicitly not recommended[1].
🔬 What changed after 2016
[ edit ]Vitamin D does not save cartilage. The Australian VIDEO randomised trial (2016) followed 413 patients with knee osteoarthritis for two years on monthly high-dose vitamin D or placebo. There was no significant difference in cartilage volume loss or pain, and the authors concluded supplementation does not slow progression[5].
Weight loss has a dose response. NICE's evidence review states that any weight loss helps, but 10% is better than 5%[1] — the cheapest, best-evidenced intervention available.
Weight-loss drugs entered the field. The 2024 STEP 9 trial randomised 407 people with obesity and moderate knee osteoarthritis to weekly semaglutide 2.4 mg or placebo for 68 weeks. Body weight fell 13.7% versus 3.2%, and the WOMAC pain score (0–100, higher is worse) fell 41.7 points versus 27.5, with better physical function; gastrointestinal upset was the main reason 6.7% discontinued[7].
Osteoarthritis is no longer framed as simple wear and tear. Current guidance describes it as a disease of the whole joint — cartilage, synovium, subchondral bone and low-grade inflammation — with flares and stable periods rather than linear decline[1][3]. That changes timing: settle inflammation during a flare, build strength between flares.
🧨 Arthroscopy: from routine to not recommended
[ edit ]The Finnish FIDELITY trial followed patients with degenerative meniscal tears randomised to arthroscopic partial meniscectomy or exercise therapy. At five years there was no difference in pain or function, and the surgery group had a slightly higher risk of radiographic osteoarthritis progression[6]. NICE therefore lists arthroscopic lavage and debridement as procedures not to offer[1]. This applies to degenerative disease; acute traumatic locking or suspected ligament injury is a different problem.
🀄 The Chinese medicine view
[ edit ]Chinese medicine classifies these symptoms as knee bi (膝痹) or bone bi. The internal cause is liver-kidney depletion and insufficient qi and blood — ageing and chronic overuse; the external cause is wind, cold and damp invading the channels, so qi and blood do not flow and pain follows. Over time phlegm and stasis can bind, deforming the joint[9][10].
Treatment is pattern-based: tonify liver and kidney and strengthen sinews and bone (formulas such as Duhuo Jisheng Tang); dispel wind, cold and damp; or invigorate blood and unblock the collaterals. External methods include acupuncture, moxibustion, tuina, herbal poultices and washes. Hong Kong's Hospital Authority runs integrated Chinese-Western medicine programmes that include acupuncture and herbal treatment for knee osteoarthritis[9].
The evidence caveat matters: NICE 2022 advises against acupuncture or dry needling for osteoarthritis[1] because pooled trials do not show clinically meaningful benefit. Chinese medicine practitioners argue that pattern-based, individualised treatment helps some patients — particularly older people who cannot take Western analgesics — but that is clinical experience rather than large-trial proof. Both statements can be true: one describes average effects across populations, the other individualised care.
🌿 Natural remedies: what the evidence says
[ edit ]EarthClinic, a long-running user-report site, lists apple cider vinegar, Epsom salt baths, DMSO, turmeric, MSM and capsaicin cream among the most-voted knee pain remedies[11]. These are anecdotes, not trials.
Some support: topical capsaicin reduces pain signalling and has trial evidence; curcumin shows benefit in several small randomised trials, though absorption varies widely between formulations.
Weak or no evidence: glucosamine and chondroitin — NICE advises against[1]; apple cider vinegar has no controlled trial in knee osteoarthritis; DMSO is not a registered medicine in Hong Kong and carries skin and solvent-purity risks.
Reasonable but modest: Epsom salt baths relax muscles rather than cartilage; heat helps stiffness, cold helps acute swelling. Any topical remedy on broken skin, or alongside anticoagulants, should be discussed with a doctor or pharmacist.
📺 How Hong Kong YouTube frames it
[ edit ]Two local channels take angles that differ from a clinic visit. Stormtrooper (白兵) approaches pain mechanically: in one video he argues that flat feet, bunions and knee, hip and shoulder pain can be improved by adjusting walking posture and using barefoot-style shoes, restoring the foot arch and the lower-limb line of force; his podcast also has an episode reviewing pain sites one by one.
偏方小百科 takes the nutrition route: videos on the mineral link to chronic joint pain, what to eat with arthritis, and three underrated nutrients for joint pain.
Both share a premise worth keeping — knee pain often reflects whole-body loading rather than one worn-out joint — which aligns with current thinking. The specific prescriptions (particular supplements, particular shoes) are not backed by large trials, so treat them as lifestyle direction rather than treatment.
🦵 Five things you can do
[ edit ]Build quadriceps strength. Sit, straighten the knee, hold five seconds; 10 repetitions, two to three sets daily.
Lose weight. Each kilogram lost removes roughly three to four kilograms of load from the knee when climbing stairs; aim for 10% of body weight[1].
Choose low-impact activity. Swimming, cycling, tai chi and brisk walking are gentler than running or jumping; NICE recommends therapeutic exercise covering strength, flexibility and aerobic work[1].
Reduce, don't stop, during a flare. Cut load-bearing activity and use short cold applications, but avoid complete bed rest, which accelerates strength loss.
Address other risk factors. Diabetes, gout and inflammatory arthritis add to knee load; very hard soles or marked flat feet change loading and may warrant an insole assessment.
⚠️ When to seek help urgently
[ edit ]Do not wait if the knee is suddenly hot, red and badly swollen (possible infection or gout), if you cannot bear weight after an injury, if the joint locks and will not straighten, if night pain persists for weeks, or if there is fever or unexplained weight loss. These fall outside ordinary degeneration and require exclusion of infection, fracture, tumour or inflammatory arthritis[4].
❓ FAQ
[ edit ]Does clicking mean the cartilage is gone?
No. Crepitus can come from gas, tendon movement or patellar tracking. Noise without pain usually needs no treatment; noise with pain, swelling or weakness does.
Do glucosamine and chondroitin work?
NICE advises against them for lack of strong evidence[1]. If a patient finds them helpful and free of side effects, that is a personal choice, but they should not replace exercise and weight management.
How long do injections last?
Steroid injections typically relieve pain for weeks to a few months; hyaluronic acid is conditionally recommended at best and does not regrow cartilage.
Is acupuncture useful?
NICE does not recommend it[1]; Chinese medicine uses it selectively by pattern, and some patients report relief. It should not delay orthopaedic assessment when that is clearly needed.
Will I need surgery?
Arthroscopic washout is not indicated for degenerative knee osteoarthritis[1][6]. The operation that matters is joint replacement, reserved for severe pain, failed conservative care and impaired quality of life.
📚 References
[ edit ]- NICE (2022). Osteoarthritis in over 16s: diagnosis and management — Recommendations (NG226)
- American College of Rheumatology: Guideline for the Management of Osteoarthritis of the Hand, Hip and Knee
- OARSI: Osteoarthritis Research Society International — Guidelines
- NHS: Knee pain — symptoms, causes and when to get help
- Jin X, et al. (2016). The VIDEO study: vitamin D supplementation in knee osteoarthritis. Osteoarthritis and Cartilage
- Røtterud JH, et al. (2020). Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy for a degenerative meniscus tear: 5-year FIDELITY follow-up. BJSM
- Bliddal H, et al. (2024). Once-Weekly Semaglutide in Persons with Obesity and Knee Osteoarthritis (STEP 9). NEJM 391:1573–1583
- Department of Health, Elderly Health Service: Osteoarthritis of the knee
- Hospital Authority: Chinese Medicine @ HA
- School of Chinese Medicine, The Chinese University of Hong Kong
- EarthClinic: Knee Pain — natural remedies and user reports
🎥 Videos
5 related videos · click to play
Play



