Probiotics are live microorganisms that, when consumed in adequate amounts, confer a health benefit on the host. They are mainly lactobacilli and bifidobacteria, but also yeasts such as Saccharomyces boulardii. The name can be broken down into three levels: genus, species, and strain—different strains of the same species can have completely different functions[2].
On the shelves of Hong Kong supermarkets, pharmacies, and personal care stores, probiotic products range from a few dozen dollars to over seven hundred dollars, with claims from "improving gut health" to "boosting immunity" and "relieving eczema." How much evidence is there for these claims? Is this the same as the "spleen and stomach" in traditional Chinese medicine? Below we break it down item by item, and list the current regulatory situation in Hong Kong and key points for purchasing.
💊 What are probiotics: genus, species, strain
[ edit ]A 2024 survey by the Consumer Council pointed out that currently 17 probiotic genera are medically confirmed to exist in the human body; products on the market are mainly lactobacilli (improving digestion, accelerating intestinal peristalsis) and bifidobacteria (producing lactic acid, B vitamins, and acetic acid)[2]. The International Scientific Association for Probiotics and Prebiotics (ISAPP) emphasizes that "true probiotics" refer to live microorganisms of a specific strain, at a specific dose, tested and proven to have health benefits; most microorganisms in fermented foods do not meet this definition because the strains and quantities are not standardized[8].
The unit of dosage is CFU (colony-forming units). The 40 samples surveyed by the Consumer Council had labeled quantities ranging from 150,000 to 50 billion CFU[2]. More is not necessarily better—different strains and different indications require vastly different doses, and excessive intake offers no additional benefit.
🩺 Uses with stronger evidence
[ edit ]The UK NHS is frank: some evidence suggests probiotics may help with certain conditions, such as relieving some symptoms of irritable bowel syndrome (IBS), but evidence for many health claims is weak—for example, there is no evidence that probiotics can treat eczema[1].
The areas with the strongest evidence are antibiotic-associated diarrhoea (AAD) and Clostridioides difficile-associated diarrhoea (CDAD). A Cochrane systematic review updated in September 2025, including 47 studies with a total of 15,260 participants, showed that probiotics may reduce the absolute risk of C. difficile diarrhoea from 3.2% to 1.6% (relative risk 0.50, 95% confidence interval 0.38–0.64), with low-certainty evidence[5]. Another umbrella review published in 2026 (21 systematic reviews and meta-analyses, involving 170 independent randomized controlled trials) reached similar conclusions: probiotics are associated with a reduced risk of antibiotic-associated diarrhoea (relative risk 0.54, 95% confidence interval 0.48–0.61), but no significant benefit was seen in the elderly group (relative risk 0.96, 95% confidence interval 0.85–1.08)[6].
For IBS, a 2024 Bayesian network meta-analysis in Nutrients (54 randomized controlled trials of probiotics) showed that probiotics overall improved IBS symptoms (odds ratio 0.53, 95% confidence interval 0.48–0.59), mainly with bifidobacteria and lactobacilli, with no serious adverse events reported; however, the most effective strain combination remains unknown, and prebiotics and synbiotics showed no significant improvement[7].
🔬 What the latest research says
[ edit ]Three trends in recent research are worth noting. First, the quality of evidence is generally low: the Cochrane 2025 review pointed out that many studies did not pre-register their trial protocols, about 30% of studies lacked a published protocol or clinical trial registration, and authors of 28 studies had conflicts of interest with probiotic companies[5]. Second, efficacy is highly "strain-specific": different strains of the same species can have opposite effects, so "taking probiotics" is not the same as "taking effective probiotics." Third, age and medical condition affect outcomes: the umbrella review above showed benefits in adults and children, but no significant benefit in the elderly group[6].
In other words: probiotics are not "good for everyone," but rather "certain strains, under certain conditions, help certain people."
🇭🇰 Hong Kong market reality and regulation
[ edit ]The Consumer Council's survey announced in January 2024 collected 40 probiotic dietary supplements (6 for women, 11 for children, 23 general) from pharmacies, personal care stores, and health product specialty stores. Prices ranged from HK$99 to HK$788, and based on daily serving size, from HK$5.3 to HK$52.6—nearly a ninefold difference[2].
Labeling problems are quite common: only 15 clearly labeled all strains, 1 labeled only strain numbers, 3 labeled only genus, 20 listed only species, and 1 had no probiotic information at all; overall, 60% of samples did not meet the requirements of international voluntary industry labeling guidelines[2]. More notably, 2 samples were labeled as containing Enterococcus faecalis/faecium—the joint FAO/WHO working group considers such strains less stable, prone to contamination or becoming pathogenic, and resistant to vancomycin, and does not recommend them for human use as probiotics[2].
Regarding regulation, the Consumer Council clearly states: there is currently no legislation or standard in Hong Kong requiring dietary supplements to provide proof of safety or efficacy, and the Consumer Council has advocated that the government refer to other markets for legislation[2]. The NHS has the same observation: probiotics are generally classified as food rather than medicine, so they do not undergo rigorous drug-level testing[1].
⚠️ Risks and contraindications
[ edit ]Most people have no problems taking probiotics; the most common are mild bloating, gas, abdominal discomfort, or diarrhoea. But the following situations require special caution:
First, premature infants or those with extremely low birth weight. The Consumer Council cited a warning from the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) that a premature infant died of sepsis caused by bifidobacteria after taking a certain probiotic formula; the FDA also noted that microorganisms in probiotics pose a risk of fatal diseases such as bacteremia in extremely premature or extremely low birth weight infants[2]. Second, immunocompromised individuals, those with central venous catheters, or critically ill patients—taking live bacteria may cause bacteremia, and a doctor must be consulted first[1]. Third, those taking antibiotics should space out the timing (generally recommended more than two hours apart) to prevent antibiotics from killing the probiotics; in practice, different products have different instructions, so follow the label or pharmacist's advice.
Also, distinguish "probiotics" from "prebiotics": prebiotics are fibers that feed good bacteria (e.g., oligosaccharides, inulin) and are not live bacteria themselves; the Consumer Council survey found that 26 samples had added prebiotics[2].
🀄 Traditional Chinese Medicine perspective
[ edit ]Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) traditionally has no concept of "gut microbiota," but it has a corresponding understanding of intestinal ecological imbalance. Registered TCM practitioner Dr. Ku Hoi Lun points out that sticky, soft stools are mostly related to body constitution, commonly "spleen deficiency" or "damp-heat in the spleen and stomach," and are closely related to dietary habits (more sticky, greasy foods, less fruits and vegetables/fiber)[9]. This explanation can actually be compared with modern medicine's statement that "gut microbiota is affected by diet," but the language and diagnostic logic of the two are completely different—TCM uses pattern differentiation and treatment, looking at overall constitution; Western medicine focuses on strains and clinical trial results.
Dr. Ku's suggested approach to regulation is to strengthen the spleen and remove dampness, with commonly used ingredients including Chinese yam, coix seed, hyacinth bean, and lotus seed; he also mentions that daily probiotic supplementation and reducing sweets and chocolate can improve stool consistency[9]. Note that Chinese herbal medicines (e.g., formulas like Shenling Baizhu San) and probiotics have different mechanisms of action and should not replace each other; if you have spleen and stomach symptoms, you should have a registered TCM practitioner prescribe based on pattern differentiation, rather than taking over-the-counter medicines long-term on your own.
🛒 How to choose and take (Hong Kong practicalities)
[ edit ]When purchasing, follow these principles: 1. Check clearly the genus, species, and strain number (e.g., Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG); products with only species names are less convincing[2]; 2. Check the CFU count and expiry date—the labeled quantity should be "at expiry" not "at manufacture"; 3. Avoid products containing Enterococcus faecalis/faecium[2]; 4. Choose strains with clear indications and research support, not just "multi-strain formulas"; 5. Check whether the packaging indicates the appropriate age; children and infants should not take adult doses[2].
Regarding administration, most products recommend taking on an empty stomach or before meals, but different products have different requirements, so follow the label; if taking antibiotics at the same time, remember to space them out. Pregnant women, those with chronic illnesses, and immunocompromised individuals should consult a doctor before taking[1].
❓ Frequently asked questions
[ edit ]💡 Q: Can probiotics treat eczema?
A: The NHS clearly states there is no evidence that probiotics can treat eczema[1]; the Consumer Council also cited doctors saying that claims of probiotics improving eczema lack large-scale clinical evidence[2].
Q: Do I have to take probiotics when taking antibiotics?
A: Not necessarily. The Cochrane 2025 review shows probiotics may reduce the risk of C. difficile diarrhoea, but this is low-certainty evidence[5]; whether to take them should be decided by a doctor based on risk assessment, and they should be taken spaced apart from antibiotics.
💡 Q: Are more CFU better?
A: No. The Consumer Council survey samples ranged from 150,000 to 50 billion CFU[2]; different strains require different effective doses, and excessive amounts offer no additional benefit but increase the chance of gastrointestinal discomfort.
💡 Q: Can children take probiotics?
A: Some strains have research support for children, but there are clear risks for infants, especially premature infants; the FDA has issued a warning about a premature infant death[2]; children should consult a doctor before taking, and follow the minimum age on the product label.
Q: What is the difference between probiotics and prebiotics?
A: Probiotics are live bacteria; prebiotics are fibers that feed good bacteria (e.g., oligosaccharides, inulin) and do not contain live bacteria themselves; in the Consumer Council survey, 26 samples also contained prebiotics[2].
📚 References
[ edit ]- NHS: Probiotics
- Consumer Council: Don't take probiotics blindly (survey of 40 samples, 2024)
- Cleveland Clinic: Probiotics
- Wikipedia: Probiotic
- Cochrane 2025: Probiotics for preventing C. difficile diarrhoea
- Front Nutr 2026: Umbrella review on antibiotic-associated diarrhoea
- Nutrients 2024: Network meta-analysis for IBS treatment
- ISAPP: Consumer information
- HK01: Gut health — why stools stick (Dr. Ku Hoi Lun, registered Chinese medicine practitioner)
🎥 Videos
4 related videos · click to play
Play


